i. "this is our island," you told me. you said it like i didn't already know. "this is ours." just to remind me.
"i know," i said. i expected it to taste like bile and cigarette butts, but it was empty and we said little after that. my eyes, dimmed, too, swept around the scenery: you with your hands digging in your pockets, looking for a lighter already; blackbirds, maybe crows, lining the tree across the river, or what was left of it. the entire bed was empty and dry, and that's how everything felt - empty and dry. cold and clear. yet somehow, arid. stifling.
neither of us could catch a breath, to say the least.
the dust was picking up and it was windy. you, encircling me, enfolding me in your arms. you, whispering something - me, not listening, not even for a second. your fingers graced the surface of my skin and i did not flinch when the end of your cigarette - still lit - traced a shaky path alongside it. i just closed my eyes. i must not have been breathing because i couldn't see it in front of me, and everything was so cold that was all that was really left. the water was gone and we were no longer an island - or standing on one, i should say. the log we used to cross over was long-dead and rotted, caved in on the middle. i was the first to walk across and i fell straight through. probably you laughed - you must have. but i don't think you said anything about it, and neither did i.
the cup we left from before was still there, sitting on the rocks. it was a lonely island of itself.
i picked it up, opened my mouth a little, and looked at you. your stare was blank but i think you saw it was coming. i pivoted, just slightly, and threw it as hard as i could.
ii. the birds picked up and flew off, and the next thing i know, i am sitting on a train.
everything is blue. it's a bit like looking at the world through the lens of a camera - one minute, sepia, the next, cyan. warmer than that, though. deeper. darker.
i had only ever been on a train once in my life, when i was little. i think it was for easter. now, i don't know what the month is, or the occasion, but i'm sitting turning a cup in my hands on the table. if i'm not mistaken, it's the same one.
i shake my head and stand up to walk away, but i bump into someone wearing dark grey.
words have left me entirely. i open my mouth to speak but find nothing and try to just shuffle past. whoever it is stops me, grabs my wrist, gently but with authority i can't place. the hand is rough, well-worn, but warm. i look down and then up. a change of scenery - again. not a boy but not near a man either. blue eyes. blond hair. questionable expression.
i expect him to say something, but words must have left him, too. we pause for a moment and then he lets go; i look down, and move on down the aisle. i do not hear his footsteps in one direction or the other but i don't dare turn around.
the tension is stifling.
"wait."
somebody says it. i do not know who. but it was what we were both thinking, and i stop.
iii. my hands, balled into fists at my sides. his, shuffling in his pockets, fiddling with his thumbs, crossing his arms. i look up, and the train lurches to a halt.
cups and chandelier lights, shaking. him, grabbing the seats on either sides to steady himself. me, too frozen to think, suddenly falling and colliding with him. hands grabbing fistfuls of shirts and then, nothing.
the train has steadied and stopped, now, but we're still holding each other. we needed an excuse and we basked in it, like a serpent coiled in the sunlight. a reason - that was it.
but i can't do it. not yet. i uncoil myself from him and push my palms against his chest and i do not dare look up to meet his eyes. i can feel them already, and seeing them would be too much. we are of little words and somehow i am still the first to speak. "what?" that's all i can manage.
"you're bleeding," he says. his voice is thick with concern and only now do i look up. how i didn't notice it before, i have no idea, but there is a gash across my cheek and soon my whole mouth is metallic salt. my eyes are blank but full of fear. not for the blood - but everything else.
"let me help you," he tries, and takes a cautionary step toward me. my nerves stand up on end and my head screams a heavy no. but my body, automatic, leans into it and i think i say 'okay'. my eyes squeeze shut, hard enough for colours to turn circles over everything. hard enough to forget where i am, who i'm with, what i'm doing. hard enough to stay still when a hand, his, traces my jawline and the train begins to move again.
Positives:
-The lack of capitals and sentence structure.
A frequent theme in your writing, I believe here in a longer piece, and set up as you have, it really adds a lilting flow, adding to the dissociative, dream-like quality of the piece.
- The picture painted
While reading this, the environement is constructed beautifully and it becomes like watching a video. Every sense is indulged through rich description.
- The amount of emotion & anti-emotion
The piece varies between being an emotional roller coaster and a having a looking-glass quality. At times, the reader is drenched in the emotions of confusion, fear, desire.
The anti-emotion of the piece is built through the transient state of the ever-changing setting and the character's lack of response to some of the environemnt.
- The repetition of subjects
Repetively mentioning the birds, the train, the cup, etc. All of these objects add an interesting and different perspective on the story and the character.
Critiques:
- Beginning vs. Ending
I would like to agree with the previous critique. I believe that the ending could have tied in more with the beginning. Maybe not through revision but through the addition of another part.
- Expanding on certain emotions
At times I felt that there could have been 3 -5 words to describe something versus just stating it. As in, "The tension is stifling." ... "my eyes are blank but full of fear"...
- The ending.
This ties in with the first point of critique. I just feel like you're waiting for something. I am going to guess that is intentional, yet it doesn't pack the punch I'd expect.
Overall, this piece is outstanding. It paints such a real picture, and the metaphors, the scenery, the atmosphere...
It's a very amazing piece.
Onto the actual deviation. It's very dream like, and I'm almost disappointed that that's the explanation. The writing is so lovely, so unique and half aware that to have such a concrete explanation is a bit of a let down. That's not your fault in any way, though, and I'll put it aside as I assess your wonderful work here.
The first chapter is by far my favorite. Your imagery, the cautious dialog, the atmosphere is just lovely. It's a beautiful scene you've painted.
One issue: tenses. Make them consistent, because as is, it's a bit confusing. I can't tell if you're lapsing into a memory or in the present.
Also, the end to this chapter is good It's a solid conclusion, which is hard to achieve with an action, but you did it well. I like the mention of the cup because it's intriguing, but you don't clarify what the cup is later, which is a bit frustrating. Perhaps you could without completely diminishing the mystery.
Chapter two has a rather blatant transition in it's beginning, and though I know dreams tend to do that, I think you could revise it to be better.
The rest of it is very good- great descriptions, definite suspense, good end. It's a perfect middle.
The last chapter is confusing. Everything you've written is fabulous, but it as this is the finale of the piece, there should be a thread connecting it to the beginning. I know in the dream there may not have been that connection, but this should be an adaptation of the dream into a story, and to make it a story, you have to finish the plot.
Also. the last chapter is all action, in contrast to the first. You need to slow down and explain a bit so the reader can keep up.
There's a sense, and implication that this man in the last two chapters is the same as the one in the first. But you don't give confirmation of that, and it makes the reader very unsure. I think you should. And that can be the conclusion, is that knowledge of the man being a singularity. You don't need to directly state it, just maybe mention a detail twice, like him searching in his pockets or wearing grey.
Overall, this is an incredible foundation and a very good deviation. I hope some of the suggestions I offered are helpful in editing!
The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork
Please sign up or login to post a critique.